The answer, as with many things in the law is -- it depends. Before answering the question with a little more clarity, let me explain what a will is. A will is a legal document that allows you to designate where your property goes when you die, who you want to be in charge of making sure the property goes where it is supposed to go and appoint guardians and conservators for your minor children.
If you do not have a will and you die, then your property passes by what are called the laws of intestacy. In other words, Massachusetts has a law which says how property is distributed if you die and you do not have a will.
Regardless of whether you have a will, some of your property may not pass via the instructions in your will. Insurance policies and retirement accounts pass to the person or people you designated in those documents that you filled out when you bought the policy or with your human resources office or investment broker. Real estate held as tenants by the entirety or held as joint tenants passes to the survivor listed on the deed. Bank accounts held jointly also automatically become the property of the other owner of the account.
If you own nothing in your own name, not even your car and all of your major assets are tied up in jointly held real estate, insurance policies or retirement funds, you may think you do not need a will. I would still advocate that you should have one anyway. Why leave it to the legislature to decide where your money should go? You may also have some personal property such as a wedding ring or fine china that you want to designate to certain loved ones.
In addition to the will, you may need other estate planning documents such as a durable power of attorney, a health care proxy and one or more trusts. You should consult a lawyer about what works best for you depending on your finances and your personal situation.
In 1774, Lord Mansfield said "Possession is nine points of the law". Our practice handles disputes over a very important possession -- land, be it landlord/tenant, lease disputes or homeowner-contractor litigation. This blog will explore substantive issues as well as those nine points of law to which Lord Mansfield refers.
Thursday, March 10, 2016
Monday, March 7, 2016
Hiring a home improvement contractor
It is that time of year -- the "for sale" signs are up, and the crocuses will be up soon. As we joke in our family, very shortly, the for sale sign comes down and the dumpster appears in the driveway and the building permit in the window. Whether you are buying a new home and renovating or sprucing up the house you have, here are some things to consider before you let a contractor do work on your house.
- Contractors in Massachusetts should have both a home improvement contractor registration and a construction supervisor license. Make sure your contractor has both.
- Ask friends, family, colleagues, and neighbors for referrals. Receiving a referral from someone you know is often the best way to find the best person to do the job. But don't rely solely on the referral. Do your homework.
- Make sure that the contractor can do the job for you. In other words, if the contractor mostly renovates kitchen, he may not be the right person to bump out that dormer on the second floor.
- Ask the contractor for the names of the last 3 projects he has completed or is presently working on. Also, ask to visit one or more of his current work sites. If a contractor will only give you references make sure that the projects were completed in the last year.
- Find out what kind of insurance your contractor has. Keep in mind that it is rare that a contractor has insurance that will pay you for a claim that the contractor was negligent. Most policies exclude poor workmanship from coverage.
- Make sure you have a contract in writing and that the contract includes basic items like payment terms, termination, and language required by Massachusetts law.
Wednesday, March 2, 2016
Month to Month Tenancies
When we receive a call at the office from a potential tenant client, the first thing we need to determine is the type of tenancy the tenant has. If you have no written lease, then the tenant has a month to month tenancy. That means that the landlord or the tenant can terminate the rental relationship on one full month's notice.
Not having a lease has advantages and disadvantages for both landlord and tenant. If you are a tenant, no lease means you can move fairly easily and quickly. This can be great if you don't like the place, get noisy neighbors or decide to purchase a home. It can be less than ideal because the landlord can require you move on as little as 30 days' notice for any reason that is not discriminatory. The landlord can also seek to raise your rent at anytime. If you receive a notice to quit and do not have a lease, you will need to move. There may be some negotiating with the landlord to figure out a time that is mutually convenient, but ultimately, you must move. This is true even if you have lived in the unit for a very long time.
From the landlord's perspective, not having a lease gives you the freedom to evict someone without reason. For example, if a tenant has lease, is paying rent and generally abiding by the terms of the lease, but the landlord just does not like the tenant (for some non-discriminatory reason), the landlord does not have grounds to evict the tenant and must live with the tenant through the end of the lease term. With no lease, a landlord can send a notice to quit and with any luck, the tenant will move. The tenant can have the property available on reasonably short notice for a friend or relative who needs a place to live. You may also be able to charge a bit of a premium as there are certain groups of people in need of temporary housing. These would include people doing renovations on their home (either by choice or because of some sort of catastrophe), people moving out of their residence because of a divorce, people relocating, and people with temporary job assignments, just to name a few. The disadvantages for the landlord are that the tenant could leave at anytime and you could end up with a bit of a revolving door at your unit. Re-renting a place takes time, effort and expense. You also do not have the chance to specify rules or regulations that you wish to have followed.
So when is it better to have a lease as a tenant? If you plan on staying where you are for at least a year and do not want to move, you should seriously consider a lease. Similarly, if you have been in a unit for a number of years and do not want to move, you should make sure your lease is renewed. On the other hand, if you fall into any of the above categories -- recently separated or divorced, moving to a new town, or desirous of home ownership, then a month to month tenancy would be better for you, unless the landlord is willing to give you a short term lease.
From a landlord's perspective, in most cases you are better off having a lease. Your tenant is responsible for rent for twelve months and you can specify the terms of the tenancy. You can say no smoking, no waterbeds or no space heaters. You can charge a tenant for gas or electricity of separately metered. You can indicate fees for rent not paid for 30 days. However, there are a few situations when you may not want to have a lease. For example, if you purchased the property with the intention of having a family member move in and the date of move in is uncertain, then perhaps you want to rent the unit for a few months. Depending on your town, it may be easy to rent properties and you are happy with the premium you can get for rentals of several months at a time because there are always people who want to rent. You may not want a lease if you live in the same building as the rental unit and want to see if you and the tenant get along without being locked into a year long lease.
Finally, you can have a written month to month lease which could be a good combination in many circumstances. The amount of time which must be given to terminate the lease can be spelled out, so you can make it 60, rather than 30 days. The landlord also can spell out specific terms it wants included. Both sides still have flexibility in moving out, but neither side has a guarantee of housing (for the tenant) or income (for the landlord).
Labels:
eviction,
landlord,
lease,
month to month,
notice to quit,
tenant
Tuesday, November 17, 2015
What a Default in Court Means
Sometime ago, I blogged about the perils of
ignoring a lawsuit. The decision we received from the Appeals Court last
week underscored the danger of failing to participate in the litigation
process. The appellant made a conscious decision to refrain from
participating in the underlying litigation.
He failed to answer the Verified Complaint, he failed to attend his
deposition, he failed to attend the assessment hearing personally to offer
testimony to counter that of our client. His counsel did not
cross-examine our client at the assessment hearing, nor did he submit a brief
regarding the legal issue raised during the assessment of damages. The
appellant also failed to participate in a number of related actions including
two companion cases in Middlesex County.
When a default is entered against a
party, the factual allegations of the Verified Complaint are taken as true, and
each of the claims against the defaulted party must be considered established
as a matter of law. Multi Technology, Inc. v. Mitchell Mgmt.Sys., Inc.,
25 Mass.App.Ct. 333, 334-335 (1988).
"Such is the peril of a default. [Appellant's] failure to answer,
or to respond to deposition notices and other discovery requests, deprived
[Appellee] of any opportunity to supplement the factual record; the judge was
permitted to take into account the fact that Appellant not only defaulted, but
stonewalled discovery. See Multi Technology, Inc., supra at 335-336
("In reaching [her] conclusions, [the judge] was allowed to hear any
evidence material and relevant to the claims alleged in the complaint").
Cf. Mass.R.Civ.P.37(b),
as amended, 423 Mass. 1406 (1996) (setting forth sanctions for discovery
violations). [Appellant] cannot have it both ways." Erez v. Batrin, 2015
Mass. App. Unpub. LEXIS 1046 (Mass.App.Ct. 2015).
Deciding whether to fight a lawsuit or let a default enter must be a calculated decision based on the amount of money at stake, the amount of money you will have to spend to defend, whether the judgment could include an award of attorney's fees for or against you and, of course, the merits of your claim. The Rules of Civil Procedure were amended in 2013 to require that plaintiffs provide defendants with notice of the damages sought prior to an assessment of damages. However, by the time you receive this paperwork, a default has already been entered against you. In other words, the only question is the amount of damages that will be awarded - not whether you are liable. You should consult with an attorney to assist you in making that determination as these factors can be complicated.
Tuesday, November 10, 2015
The Business of Your Business
Often times, I meet with clients who are starting their own
business and need some advice. Should
they incorporate? Do they need
insurance? How do they manage their
finances? When I talk to clients about
these issues, I like to talk about managing the “business of the business”. Doing so is not always fun or what we want to
do as business owners. Let’s face it – a
painter would rather be painting than sending out bills. A caterer would rather be in the kitchen than
thinking about whether and how to take credit cards. However,
failing to do so can be detrimental to your business. It is like having a rose bush and never
pruning it. Both will quickly get out of
control. This will, of course, only take
more time and cost you more money, than if you had managed it regularly in the
first place.
Labels:
business,
corporate formalities,
corporations
Tuesday, November 3, 2015
Selecting a Jury
As I sat in court in May and again in October, selecting my seventh and eighth juries for trials, I thought a bit about the process and how odd it must seem to someone who is called for jury duty. I have actually had jury duty many times and even sat on a jury. I know that when you are called for jury duty, you watch a video, but I thought I'd give a little bit of insight into what goes on during jury selection.
First, the lawyers receive a copy of the form that you fill out when you arrive for jury duty. It contains some basic information such as where you live and work, your spouse's job, interactions with the legal system, age and how much education you have had. We get a chance to review those papers before you are chosen for jury duty.
After asking questions of the pool as a whole, the judge will start to "fill the box". There are two general ways of doing this. Some judges like to question each and every potential juror to make sure that they are unbiased and able to serve. One judge shared with the attorneys that he feels that when you speak to a juror and ask them to serve, they are more likely to do so. Other jurors will put the required number of jurors in the box and then will call up jurors who answered one of the general questions of for whom a lawyer has a question. In either event, the lawyers end up huddled around the judge. You may wonder what they are doing. In all likelihood, they are discussing one or more of the jurors sitting in the jury box.
When your number is called to sit in the jury box, there are a few things that can happen. If the judge is speaking people before they are seating in the box, then the prospective juror can explain his or her answer to any question and lawyers are given the opportunity then to raise any issues or concerns they have about that juror. Ultimately, you can either be excused from jury duty by the court or by the lawyers. The court will excuse a juror for cause -- perhaps there is a language issue, where the juror cannot fully understand English, perhaps the juror knows one of the parties or one of the attorneys or perhaps the juror has some other connection to the facts of the case that make it so he or she cannot be objective. These are some of the reasons, that the court decides someone is not able to sit on that jury.
Attorneys also get what are called peremptory challenges. These challenges allow attorneys to remove people from the jury any reason or perhaps even no reason, so long as it is not for a discriminatory reason. For example, the attorney may decide that due to the nature of the case, he or she feels that it would be better if tradespeople (plumbers, electricians, etc.) were not on the jury. An attorney can use a challenge to remove people of those professions from the jury. An attorney can remove someone because of where they live or their education level. You will not know why you are not hearing the case as a juror -- you will just know that you are not sitting on that jury.
Hopefully, this post gives you some insight into what is going on during jury selection the next time you are called for jury duty.
Epilogue: I wrote this article last week not knowing that today, the Supreme Court heard arguments about a 30 year old case involving peremptory challenges. Apparently, 20 years after the case was tried, the defendant's attorneys obtained a copy of the prosecutor's notes from the jury from a Freedom of Information Act request (or the equivalent under Georgia law). This case highlights the problems with peremptory challenges when it is used for discriminatory reasons.
First, the lawyers receive a copy of the form that you fill out when you arrive for jury duty. It contains some basic information such as where you live and work, your spouse's job, interactions with the legal system, age and how much education you have had. We get a chance to review those papers before you are chosen for jury duty.
After asking questions of the pool as a whole, the judge will start to "fill the box". There are two general ways of doing this. Some judges like to question each and every potential juror to make sure that they are unbiased and able to serve. One judge shared with the attorneys that he feels that when you speak to a juror and ask them to serve, they are more likely to do so. Other jurors will put the required number of jurors in the box and then will call up jurors who answered one of the general questions of for whom a lawyer has a question. In either event, the lawyers end up huddled around the judge. You may wonder what they are doing. In all likelihood, they are discussing one or more of the jurors sitting in the jury box.
When your number is called to sit in the jury box, there are a few things that can happen. If the judge is speaking people before they are seating in the box, then the prospective juror can explain his or her answer to any question and lawyers are given the opportunity then to raise any issues or concerns they have about that juror. Ultimately, you can either be excused from jury duty by the court or by the lawyers. The court will excuse a juror for cause -- perhaps there is a language issue, where the juror cannot fully understand English, perhaps the juror knows one of the parties or one of the attorneys or perhaps the juror has some other connection to the facts of the case that make it so he or she cannot be objective. These are some of the reasons, that the court decides someone is not able to sit on that jury.
Attorneys also get what are called peremptory challenges. These challenges allow attorneys to remove people from the jury any reason or perhaps even no reason, so long as it is not for a discriminatory reason. For example, the attorney may decide that due to the nature of the case, he or she feels that it would be better if tradespeople (plumbers, electricians, etc.) were not on the jury. An attorney can use a challenge to remove people of those professions from the jury. An attorney can remove someone because of where they live or their education level. You will not know why you are not hearing the case as a juror -- you will just know that you are not sitting on that jury.
Hopefully, this post gives you some insight into what is going on during jury selection the next time you are called for jury duty.
Epilogue: I wrote this article last week not knowing that today, the Supreme Court heard arguments about a 30 year old case involving peremptory challenges. Apparently, 20 years after the case was tried, the defendant's attorneys obtained a copy of the prosecutor's notes from the jury from a Freedom of Information Act request (or the equivalent under Georgia law). This case highlights the problems with peremptory challenges when it is used for discriminatory reasons.
Tuesday, October 27, 2015
Changing the Locks and Providing Keys
A tenant calls the landlord and explains that she is under imminent threat of domestic violence, rape, sexual assault or stalking at her apartment and that she wants the locks changed. What can a landlord do? What must a landlord do?
If the perpetrator is not a resident of the unit, the landlord is required to change the locks within two business days upon a tenant's request. Prior to doing so, the landlord may request proof of the tenant's status as a victim and the landlord may request the perpetrator's name. The landlord may also charge the tenant a reasonable fee for changing the locks.
If the perpetrator is a resident of the same unit as the victim, then the victim must provide the landlord with a valid restraining order (protective order) from the court or a statement from law enforcement, that indicates the perpetrator poses an imminent threat.
If the tenant makes the request of the landlord and the landlord does not change the locks within two business days, then the tenant may change the locks without the landlord's permission. If a tenant does this, the new lock must be the same or better quality than the old lock and if the lease provides, promptly provide a key to the landlord. If the landlord takes action to prevent the tenant from changing the locks, the landlord is liable for the greater of three months' rent or actual or consequential damages, plus reasonable attorney's fees.
Owners who act in good faith are not subject to damages and owners who refuse to provide a key to someone based on the reasonable belief that he or she is the perpetrator of a rape, sexual assault, stalking or domestic violence, are not liable.
The takeaway for landlords is that if you have a tenant who claims to be the victim of domestic violence, rape, assault or stalking and wants the locks changed, you must act quickly. Verify the veracity of the tenant's story and if true, then change the locks promptly. Document everything. If a tenant calls you to make this request, you can start to act on it, but have the tenant follow up in writing. Obtain verification in writing and keep a copy for your file. If the perpetrator asks for a copy of the key and you refuse to provide one, make a note in the tenant's file.
Labels:
domestic violence,
landlord,
rape,
sexual assault,
stalking,
tenant
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)